Facts, examples, myths, and talking points to help youth advocates confidently communicate about decriminalisation in their communities.
Designed PDF edition coming soon to the publications library
Decriminalisation is one of the most misunderstood terms in drug policy debates. Getting the definition right is the starting point for every effective conversation.
The Policy Spectrum: where decriminalisation sits on the drug policy spectrum, from more punitive to more health-centred: Full Prohibition, Mandatory Minimums, De facto Tolerance, Decriminalisation, Legal Regulation.
Knowing what decriminalisation does NOT mean is just as important as knowing the definition. Misinformation spreads fast, be ready to correct it clearly and calmly.
| Decriminalisation IS... | Decriminalisation is NOT... |
|---|---|
| Removing criminal records for personal drug use | Legalisation, drugs remain controlled substances |
| A public health response to substance use | Giving up on drug prevention or education |
| Redirecting resources from prisons to health services | Allowing open drug markets or sales |
| Protecting dignity and human rights of people who use drugs | Saying drug use is safe or consequence-free |
| Supported by UNODC, WHO, UNAIDS, and the UN Secretary-General | Removing all penalties, administrative responses may still apply |
| Evidence-based: linked to reduced HIV transmission and overdose deaths | A policy that promotes drug use in young people |
| Keeping drug supply regulations and trafficking offences intact | Making trafficking or supply legal in any way |
| Issue | Decriminalisation | Legalisation |
|---|---|---|
| Drug sales | Remain illegal and criminal | May be permitted within a regulated system |
| Personal possession | Removed from criminal codes | Permitted up to a specified quantity |
| Drug markets | Still unregulated and illegal | Can be formally licensed and taxed |
| Production | Remains illegal | May be licensed and regulated |
| International treaties | Generally compatible | May conflict with UN drug conventions |
| Examples | Portugal, Czech Republic, Ghana (partial) | Uruguay, Canada (cannabis), several US states |
These are the most frequently heard objections to decriminalisation. Know them well, and respond with evidence, not emotion.
Decriminalisation will make young people use more drugs.
Evidence consistently shows that decriminalisation does not significantly increase drug use rates. In Portugal, after decriminalisation in 2001, problematic drug use decreased by over 40% among young people. Drug use is driven by social, economic, and psychological factors, not the legal status of possession. Fear of arrest already keeps few people from using.
Decriminalisation sends the message that drugs are OK.
Decriminalisation is a health policy, it doesn't endorse drug use any more than needle exchange programmes encourage injection. In fact, countries that have decriminalised typically invest more in prevention, education, and treatment, not less. The message it sends is: "We treat addiction as a health issue, not a moral failing."
Africa/our country is not ready for decriminalisation.
Several African countries already practise de facto decriminalisation. South Africa's Constitutional Court has confirmed the right to use cannabis privately. Kenya and Ghana have active civil society campaigns for reform. Many African nations had harm-reduction traditions before colonial drug laws were imposed. Decriminalisation is not foreign, it is a return to community care.
Decriminalisation only works in rich countries like Portugal.
Portugal was not a wealthy country when it decriminalised in 2001, it was recovering from economic hardship. Multiple low- and middle-income countries, including Czech Republic, Ecuador, Mexico, Uruguay, and several Caribbean nations, have implemented decriminalisation or legal regulation models. The key is political will and investment in health systems, both achievable at different scales.
Decriminalisation will increase crime and drug trafficking.
Drug trafficking is still a criminal offence under decriminalisation, nothing changes on supply-side enforcement. In practice, decriminalisation frees up police resources to focus on trafficking rather than chasing personal users. In Portugal, drug-related deaths, HIV infections, and incarceration rates all decreased significantly after decriminalisation.
Religious and traditional values are incompatible with decriminalisation.
Many faith traditions emphasise compassion, healing, and non-judgement, all core principles of health-based drug policy. Religious leaders in Ghana, South Africa, and the Pacific have spoken in support of harm reduction. Decriminalisation does not require approving of drug use, it requires treating people with dignity. These are not opposing values.
We don't have enough treatment services, so decriminalisation won't work.
Decriminalisation is not a standalone policy, it should be implemented alongside investment in health and social services. However, continuing to criminalise personal use diverts funding from treatment to policing and prisons. Decriminalisation creates fiscal space to redirect those resources into health systems. Starting the reform now builds the political momentum needed to fund services.
Decriminalisation is not theoretical, it has been implemented in dozens of countries across every region. Here are key examples for advocates in Africa, Oceania, and Europe.
Different audiences need different messages. Use these tailored talking points to meet people where they are, whether speaking to parents, faith leaders, community elders, health workers, or young people.
Find common ground first: family, community, youth futures, health, dignity.
Ask what they know and what their concerns are before launching into talking points.
Acknowledge their concern: "Yes, we all want to protect youth from drugs, AND we know criminal records make their situations worse."
Don't overwhelm with data. Choose the single most relevant talking point and develop it well.
Offer to follow up. Credibility is built on honesty, not bluffing.